Top Risks Facing Dietary Supplement Companies And How Insurance Can Help

Strive Insurance | Risk Management for Health & Wellness Brands
The dietary supplement industry is booming, but increased scrutiny and risk come with growth. Whether manufacturing multivitamins, protein powders, herbal blends, or specialty capsules, your business sits at the intersection of health, compliance, marketing, and manufacturing liability.
At Strive Insurance, we specialize in helping dietary supplement companies in Texas and beyond navigate these complex risks with tailored insurance solutions.
​
Here are the supplement brands' top exposures and how insurance can protect your business.

1. Product Liability and Bodily Injury Claims
If a consumer becomes ill, experiences an adverse reaction, or even misuses your product, your company could face a lawsuit, regardless of whether you're the manufacturer or private label distributor.

Product Liability Insurance can help with:

• Legal defense costs
• Medical damages and settlements
• Claims involving allergic reactions or side effects

Even when you're not at fault, defense costs alone can be financially devastating.

2. Labeling and Marketing Misrepresentation
Claims like “clinically proven,” “natural,” or “FDA approved” are often targeted by regulators and trial attorneys. If your label or advertising is challenged for being misleading or unsubstantiated, your company could face fines or class-action lawsuits.

Errors & Omissions (E&O) Insurance and Advertising Injury Coverage can assist with:

• Legal costs for false claims allegations
• Defense against class-action suits
• Regulatory investigation expenses

These policies are essential for any brand marketing direct-to-consumer.

3. Product Recalls
A contamination event, formulation error, or undisclosed allergen can trigger a product recall—voluntary or mandatory. The costs of notifying customers, pulling products from shelves, and managing PR fallout can cripple a small to mid-sized supplement business.
Product Recall Insurance can cover:

• Recall logistics and disposal
• Crisis management and brand repair
• Lost revenue and restocking costs

Without it, your reputation—and bottom line could suffer long-term damage.

4. Contract Manufacturing Risks
If you're using third-party manufacturers, you may be held liable for their mistakes. If they cut corners or use tainted ingredients, your brand is still on the label—and therefore, on the hook.

Contingent Liability Insurance and Vendor Management Endorsements help protect your business when your suppliers or co-packers fail to deliver safely or compliantly.

5. Cybersecurity and Customer Data
Online supplement sales are huge, but they come with data risks. E-commerce breaches, stolen credit card data, or compromised health information can lead to serious liabilities under laws like HIPAA or state privacy statutes.

Cyber Liability Insurance covers:

• Ransomware and data breach response
• Legal notification requirements
• Reputation management and loss of business

For brands that sell online or store customer data, this is a must.

6. Regulatory Scrutiny
The FDA, FTC, and state health departments monitor the supplement space closely. Even a minor compliance error in packaging or claims can lead to warnings, fines, or bans.

Regulatory Defense Coverage helps with:

• Legal costs tied to agency inquiries
• Responding to FDA 483 letters or warning letters
• Managing regulatory investigations and hearings

It’s about being prepared for more than just accident-regulators can shut you down, too.

Why Supplement Companies Need Better Protection
From Austin startups to Dallas-based contract manufacturers, Texas has a fast-growing nutraceutical scene. However, it also faces increasing consumer and regulatory pressure. Generic insurance just doesn’t cut it in this industry.

How Strive Insurance Helps
At Strive Insurance, we understand the supplement space. Our advisors know how to spot hidden gaps in coverage, build robust recall and liability protections, and help you stay compliant and covered—even if you're scaling fast.